Dinesh Karthik Weighs in on Pant vs Dhoni: Best Test Wicketkeeper-better Debate, Says ‘Unacceptable’

Add as a preferred source on Google

Former Indian wicketkeeper-batter Dinesh Karthik weighed in on the Pant vs Dhoni debate, urging patience before anointing Pant as India's greatest wicketkeeper-batter. Speaking to Cricbuzz, Karthik said, "It's very unacceptable to say that he's played 34 Tests and he's already India's greatest wicketkeeper batter."

He urged fans to have patience to see how great Pant becomes in the future. He said, "Let's take time, let's not jump to conclusions but definitely he's on course for sure, and he will finish as India's greatest ever wicketkeeper."

Karthik emphasized the need to respect Dhoni's credentials not just as a batter, but also as a wicketkeeper and a captain who led India to the No. 1 ranking in Test cricket. He noted, "Don't discount Dhoni's credentials as a wicketkeeper as well."

He added, "He [Dhoni] not only kept brilliantly, batted and scored runs when it mattered very very well for India but also he led India to a World Test Championship mace, becoming number 1. So, you've got to give all that weightage when you speak about a player all-round."

Rishabh Pant's remarkable return to Test cricket, marked by a century against Bangladesh, reignited discussions about his standing among India's great wicketkeeper-batters, especially in comparison to the legendary MS Dhoni.

After a 650-day hiatus due to a horrific car accident, Pant's 109 in the first Test not only helped India secure a 280-run win but also saw him equaling Dhoni's record for most Test centuries by an Indian wicketkeeper - both have six.

However, this debate over whether Pant has surpassed Dhoni has gained momentum, particularly on social media and among cricket experts. Especially after Delhi Capitals which the team Pant captains in the Indian Premier League, their owner Parth Jindal said the same thing on social media.

Statistically, Pant's six centuries in just 34 Tests, compared to Dhoni's six in 90, does make the case for Pant's rapid ascent. Additionally, Pant averages 44.79 in Tests, while Dhoni finished his Test career with an average of 38.09. However, Dhoni's 256 catches and 38 stumpings, along with his 27 wins in 60 Tests as captain, cement his legacy in Indian cricket.

Pant, for his part, has often been compared to Dhoni but has repeatedly expressed his desire to carve his own path. Speaking to JioCinema, Pant said, "For me, like I have said before, I want to be myself. I don't focus on what's being said or what's happening around me. I keep things simple and focus on giving my best."