Rohit Sharma's IPL form - especially his struggles against genuine pace and swing, along with his inconsistency - should ideally be enough to spark a conversation in the BCCI and the selection panel.
He's not just another player; he's the Test captain, and when your captain is clearly out of form and seemingly on the decline, it impacts not just his spot but the overall direction of the team.

Hence the question: Should Rohit step down on his own? Yes, ideally speaking. That would be the dignified move, especially from a senior statesman. It would set the tone for accountability and open up space for younger players to step in. But history shows that most greats rarely walk away voluntarily - they wait until either the selectors make the call or things get untenable.
This is not the time to be sentimental. Test cricket in England is a ruthless test of skill, fitness, and mental toughness. Rohit's recent form doesn't inspire confidence that he can anchor an innings or lead from the front, especially with the kind of bowling England has at its disposal. If India waits too long and lets Rohit call it on his own terms, it could cost the team dearly.
When a player is visibly struggling and there are hungry, in-form players knocking at the door, the writing is on the wall. The BCCI has to ask: are we picking players based on reputation or current ability? If India genuinely wants to build for the future while remaining competitive now, then tough calls have to be made. Rohit stepping aside - or being asked to - might just be one of them.
Mumbai's top order has looked unsettled, and with a casual Rohit (he doesn't need to field as well) not performing consistently or not delivering like before, it kind of muddles the setup. Right now, they're trying to fit too many pieces in without clear roles.
Dropping Rohit would be bold - especially considering his stature - but it might be necessary for the team to evolve. Otherwise, Mumbai would be out of this year's title contention for sure.
Hope a tough call on Rohit happens in and around the IPL 2025 match against the Delhi Capitals on Sunday (April 13). At least, the Mumbai owners must be talking to the support staff through war-zone meetings and should be taking a tough call very soon, who knows? How long will they be tolerant? How long?