Former Australia captain Ian Chappell has raised significant questions about the future of Indian cricket's biggest stars, Virat Kohli and Rohit Sharma, following their disappointing performances during the Border-Gavaskar Trophy (BGT).
Chappell believes that the selectors now face tough decisions as India transitions to a new phase in Test cricket. Virat Kohli, for the first time in his illustrious career, finds his Test spot under scrutiny.

Despite starting the series with a century in Perth last November, Kohli's form declined sharply, with Australian bowlers exploiting his weaknesses outside the off-stump. Across nine innings, he was caught behind eight times, managing just 190 runs at an average of 23.75. Chappell emphasized the need for Kohli to focus on the fundamentals of run-scoring while eliminating his "senseless" on-field gestures, such as shouldering Sam Konstas during the Melbourne Test.
"Kohli's experience in the UK would be invaluable, and of the two problematic players, he's the most likely to be resuscitated. However, his consistency needs to improve in addition to dispensing valuable advice to younger players," Chappell wrote on his column for Espncricinfo. He warned that Kohli's potential retirement could leave a significant void, especially as India braces for a demanding five-match tour of England starting in July.
Captain Rohit Sharma's future is equally uncertain. Following a string of low scores and his decision to opt out of the final Test in Sydney, Rohit's technical struggles and age-he turns 38 soon-pose concerns ahead of the crammed Test schedule. Chappell highlighted that Rohit's absence would not only unsettle the opening position but also raise doubts about India's leadership.
"For India, the two big question marks are leading batters, and the selectors have tough decisions to make regarding Rohit Sharma and Virat Kohli. Although India are extremely reluctant to part with star players, Rohit's form and fitness are significant concerns," Chappell explained.
India's defeat in the BGT, coupled with their failure to qualify for a third consecutive World Test Championship final, signals the need for strategic changes. The selectors face a daunting task balancing the inclusion of younger players while addressing the declining impact of two modern greats in a demanding Test schedule.