‘Why is IPL Special?’ – Mark Butcher Questions ECB’s NOC Stance After James Vince Forced to Quit First-Class For PSL

Add as a preferred source on Google

Former England cricketer Mark Butcher has questioned England and Wales Cricket Board (ECB) for their decision to give a special preference in its recently announced No Objection Certificate (NOC) policy to the Indian Premier League (IPL) over other tournaments.

ECB's new NOC policy prevents players with red-ball contracts from participating in franchise leagues during the English domestic seaso. The ECB, however, gave an exemption for players playing in the IPL, which has sparked a huge debate.

The rule has also led to one player quitting first class cricket. ECB's policy forced Hampshire captain James Vince opt for a white-ball-only contract starting from the 2025 season to continue playing in the Pakistan Super League (PSL), where he has been retained by Karachi Kings.

Speaking on the Wisden Cricket Weekly podcast, Butcher criticized the IPL exemption from ECB's NOC policy and questioned why leagues like PSL, which are pretty high standard, do not fall in the same category.

"I honestly think the biggest problem with this is the fact that they've said the IPL doesn't count. I think that's where the big issue lies. Well, why? Why is the IPL more special than any of the others? You wouldn't be able to make the case that it's more of a developmental ground for players than any of the other competitions," said Butcher.

"The PSL is a pretty high standard, so why would that one not get an exemption, whereas players are having to make big decisions about whether they play red-ball cricket or not just to play in the PSL? That creates a problem for the entire programme.

"I think it's been handled messily; that's the point. If you have one exemption from the rule, the bigger players will be able to go off and do what they want. They will largely be England-contracted players, I suppose, who won't be involved in the County Championship. But even so, to have one competition stand apart at the expense of all the others makes it a very difficult argument to justify from the ECB's perspective."