Everton and Manchester United meet at Hill Dickinson Stadium on Monday with both clubs chasing European qualification, but recent form suggests a tight contest. Michael Carrick’s side arrive unbeaten in nine Premier League matches, while David Moyes’ Everton have slipped at home and lost 2-1 to Bournemouth on 10 February, ending a five-game unbeaten league sequence.
United currently sit fourth after Carrick opened his Premier League tenure with four straight victories following Ruben Amorim’s departure last month. That run lifted the Red Devils up the table, yet their momentum slowed slightly when Benjamin Sesko needed a 96th-minute strike to rescue a point at West Ham, after Tomas Soucek had put the hosts ahead.

Carrick stressed that the late draw at London Stadium did not alter United’s general direction. "We've got to be a bit balanced in terms of not getting carried away before that [West Ham]game in terms of winning games, and certainly not getting carried away if we don't come away with the three points," Carrick said, urging perspective inside the squad.
Carrick highlighted the overall display against West Ham, pointing to control and threat in attack. "There's an understanding that games are tough to win in this league, and it's been proven, not just for us. A lot of the performance in terms of the control and how we went about the game was there. There were a lot of good things in the game. It probably got open towards the end when we were chasing it a little bit more, but we looked dangerous. And scoring a late goal is a big positive, so I think it's an important point for us. Yeah, of course, we wanted to win the game, but certainly we're not thinking that it was all bad, or it's a big negative."
Everton remain eighth despite recent home struggles, and have not celebrated a league victory in front of their supporters since beating Nottingham Forest 3-0 in December. The meeting with United starts a demanding run that also features Newcastle United, Arsenal, Chelsea and Brentford, a sequence likely to shape the Toffees’ European qualification hopes.
Moyes made clear that Everton must raise levels when facing direct rivals for European spots. "I think the big thing that I wanted us to do at Everton was to make us competitive with the so-called big teams at the top of the league," Moyes said. "And I think we have tried to do that. We haven't won all the games, but we have been competitive. We are not a team planning to fight relegation, we are a team trying to plan to challenge the teams in Europe and, to do that, we have to win some big games."
Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall is central to Everton’s attacking hopes after scoring the winner at Old Trafford in the reverse fixture. Dewsbury-Hall aims for another decisive display, and could emulate Andy King, the last English player to score in both league games for the Toffees against United in one season, back in 1978-79.
For Manchester United, captain Bruno Fernandes again carries major creative responsibility on the road. Fernandes has contributed to 10 goals across the last nine away Premier League appearances, with two goals and eight assists. Those eight away assists this season equal Ryan Giggs’ club record haul in a single Premier League campaign, set in 2001-02.
Everton won 1-0 at Old Trafford in November and now chase only a second Premier League double over United, having last achieved that feat in 2013-14, when Moyes managed the Red Devils. However, Everton’s recent home record is mixed, with five defeats in the last nine league matches at Hill Dickinson Stadium, alongside two wins and two draws.
Everton have also lacked accuracy in front of goal, averaging just 3.3 shots on target per Premier League game this season. That figure is the club’s second-lowest on record since 1997-98, better only than the 3.2 recorded in the 2017-18 campaign. United, by contrast, lead the division for total attempts, taking 417 shots so far.
United’s attacking volume under Carrick has produced their highest shots-per-game figure, 16, since the 2011-12 season, when they averaged 17. The last time United finished a Premier League campaign with the most attempts overall was 2007-08. That output supports a nine-game unbeaten league sequence, their best since a 14-match run between January and May 2021.
The visitors also have a strong historical record against Everton, particularly away from home. United have claimed 19 league victories on Everton’s turf, and 42 wins overall in this fixture, both Premier League records for one club against another. Even so, the statistical models lean towards a balanced contest at Hill Dickinson Stadium on Monday night.
OPTA’s projections show little between the sides, with Everton and Manchester United almost level and the draw slightly less likely. That reflects United’s strong form and Everton’s home concerns, but also the Toffees’ capacity to compete with top-half teams. The game therefore profiles as a tight encounter, with fine margins likely to decide whether either side secures more than a point.
| Outcome | Opta win probability |
|---|---|
| Everton | 37.1% |
| Draw | 26.3% |
| Manchester United | 36.6% |