Anthony Gordon's return to Goodison Park was marked by a missed penalty, resulting in a 0-0 draw between Newcastle United and Everton. Previously, Gordon had secured a point for Newcastle against Manchester City with a successful penalty. However, this time, his attempt was thwarted by Jordan Pickford, who celebrated the save with Everton fans.
Everton supporters directed their anger at referee Craig Pawson during the second half when Dominic Calvert-Lewin believed he deserved a penalty. Idrissa Gueye squandered a significant opportunity in that sequence. Despite these events, both teams ended up sharing the points. This result helped Sean Dyche's team move further away from relegation concerns, while Newcastle maintained their position in the top six.

From the start, Gordon faced hostility from Everton fans and tough tackles from former teammates. He drew four fouls, more than any other player on the field. When Newcastle earned a penalty, Gordon stepped up confidently but was denied by Pickford. This marked Pickford's first Premier League penalty save since May 2023, breaking a streak of eight consecutive penalties conceded.
Gordon had another chance late in the match but failed to capitalise again. Despite only having two shots, they amounted to an expected goals (xG) value of 0.87, surpassing Everton's total xG of 0.73 for the game.
The match highlighted Gordon's challenging day at Goodison Park and Pickford's crucial role in securing a point for Everton. Both teams will look to build on this result as they continue their campaigns.