Newcastle United secured their spot in the third round of the EFL Cup by defeating Nottingham Forest 4-3 on penalties after a 1-1 draw at the City Ground. Sean Longstaff netted the decisive penalty following Taiwo Awoniyi's miss for Forest.
Joe Willock gave Newcastle an early lead with one of the fastest goals in EFL Cup history, scoring just 18 seconds into the match. This early advantage set the tone for a thrilling encounter. Eddie Howe's decision to start Sandro Tonali, returning from a lengthy ban, paid off as Newcastle dominated early on.

Forest responded strongly after halftime, with Jota Silva equalising through a powerful strike. Despite this resurgence, Newcastle appeared more likely to score towards the end of regular time, with Dan Burn and Harvey Barnes both coming close.
The penalty shootout saw debutant Carlos Miguel save from Joelinton, giving Forest an initial edge. However, Ibrahim Sangare's miss hit the crossbar, allowing Newcastle back into contention. Ultimately, it was Longstaff who sealed victory for Newcastle after Awoniyi's crucial miss.
Despite Forest holding an advantage in the shootout due to Miguel's save, they squandered it with poor misses from Sangare and Awoniyi. This left Longstaff to confidently convert the winning penalty for Newcastle.
Newcastle had more shots (14 to 12) and a significantly higher expected goals (xG) tally of 1.92 compared to Forest's 0.91. These statistics highlight Newcastle's dominance despite needing penalties to secure their win.
The visitors' late efforts almost paid off, with Burn going close from a corner and Barnes hitting the side netting with a powerful shot. Howe will likely feel his team deserved their victory based on these metrics.
Sean Longstaff with the decisive spot-kick to send us into the next round of the Carabao Cup! pic.twitter.com/XHa2hGcNWk
— Newcastle United FC (@NUFC) August 28, 2024
In conclusion, Newcastle United's resilience and superior performance metrics helped them overcome Nottingham Forest in a dramatic EFL Cup tie.