The Premier League season is now 10 matches in, and the standings are starting to solidify. However, surprises are still possible. On Saturday, both Manchester City and Arsenal experienced unexpected losses against Bournemouth and Newcastle United, respectively. This marked only the third occasion since the 2017-18 season that both of the previous year's top two teams lost on the same day in the league.
Pep Guardiola's team had little reason to dispute their loss at Vitality Stadium. Andoni Iraola's Bournemouth outperformed them in expected goals (xG), with a score of 2.04 compared to City's 1.56. Meanwhile, Arsenal faced Newcastle at St James' Park, hoping to close in on Liverpool at the top of the table. Despite their efforts, Alexander Isak's early goal secured a 1-0 victory for Newcastle.

Arsenal managed to restrict Newcastle to just 0.53 xG, with Isak's goal accounting for nearly half of that figure. Only West Ham produced a lower xG over the weekend when they played with ten men against Nottingham Forest, registering just 0.13 xG. Arsenal themselves were not at their best offensively, managing only 10 attempts worth 1.05 xG.
Southampton finally claimed their first win of the season by defeating Everton 1-0 at St Mary's Stadium. Despite accumulating only 0.74 xG compared to Everton's 1.56, Adam Armstrong's late goal secured three crucial points for Southampton in their battle against relegation. Everton missed significant opportunities through Beto and Jack Harrison.
A VAR intervention also played a role as it disallowed Beto’s potential equaliser due to offside. This was Everton’s first failure to score against Southampton since February 2022, ending their five-match unbeaten streak against them in the league.
Chelsea managed a comeback draw against Manchester United at Old Trafford on Sunday evening. Moises Caicedo’s volley cancelled out Bruno Fernandes’ penalty, resulting in a 1-1 draw that denied Ruud van Nistelrooy his first league win as United’s interim coach.
Crystal Palace drew 2-2 with Wolves at Molineux despite being without key players Adam Wharton and Eberechi Eze. They generated an impressive 2.51 xG from 19 shots but failed to capitalise fully on their chances.
Ismaila Sarr missed two clear opportunities when Palace led by one goal in the second half. The game was goalless at halftime but saw both teams score twice after the break—a rare occurrence this season.
United had chances worth 1.98 xG during their match against Chelsea; however, Fernandes' penalty accounted for much of this value with an xG of 0.79 alone.
Marcus Rashford and Alejandro Garnacho squandered good opportunities for United as well—highlighting incoming manager Ruben Amorim’s task ahead with improving their attack which has netted just nine goals across ten games this season—their poorest start since scoring similarly low numbers back in the 1973-74 campaign when they faced relegation from England’s top division.
This weekend showcased how unpredictable football can be—with unexpected results shaking up expectations while providing thrilling moments throughout each matchday encounter within this competitive league environment.