India are the most under-performing white-ball team in history: Michael Vaughan

London, Nov 11: Former England captain Michael Vaughan has criticised Team India's outdated approach in the white-ball format as they bowed out of the T20 World Cup 2022. The Men In Blue lost the semi-final to England by a margin of 10 wickets as their campaign in the tournament came to a disappointing end.

Blaming the Indian Cricket Team's approach in the global competition, Vaughan on Friday (November 11) questioned what have they achieved ever since the 2011 World Cup victory. India's last ICC trophy, however, came in 2013 when they won the Champions Trophy in the UK by defeating England in the final. India's inability to win the knockout games is even earning them a dubious distinction of 'chokers'.

In his column for 'The Telegraph', Vaughan wrote, "India are the most under-performing white-ball team in history."

The 48-year-old further wrote that every player claims to have learnt so much from the Indian Premier League (IPL) but India has never managed to win a single T20 World Cup since the inception of the premier T20 league.

"Every player in the world who goes to the Indian Premier League says how it improves their game but what have India ever delivered? Since winning the 50 over World Cup on home soil in 2011 what have they done? Nothing. India are playing a white-ball game that is dated and have done for years."

Vaughan further claimed that India's approach in the shortest format of the game and team selection in the competition baffled him. Despite having the prodigiously talented Rishabh Pant in the squad, captain Rohit Sharma opted to go with veteran Dinesh Karthik in the first four Super 12 matches.

They include the dashing left-hander in the last group match against Zimbabwe and then the semifinal. But even in those two matches, Pant was under-utilised as he came in to bat at No. 5 and No. 6 respectively with hardly any overs left.

"How they have not maximised someone like Rishabh Pant is incredible. In this era, put him up the top to launch it," he wrote. "I'm just staggered by how they play T20 cricket for the talent they have. They have the players, but just do not have the right process in place. They have to go for it."

In the absence of pace spearhead Jasprit Bumarh and star all-rounder Ravindra Jadeja, the Indian bowlers cut a sorry figure while defending 169 against England as Alex Hales and Jos Buttler amassed 63 for 0 in the powerplay before achieving the target with four overs to spare.

Vaughan wrote, "Why do they give the opposition bowlers the first five overs to bed in? They have a left-armer in Arshdeep Singh who swings it back into the right-handers. So what do they do defending 168? They put on Bhuvneshwar Kumar bowling outswing to give Jos Buttler and Alex Hales width."

"Where is the left-arm seamer swinging it in to Buttler and Hales in the first over? "Madness. Cramp them for room. Do not give them a chance to get off to a flyer in the first over and settle nerves," he further added.

Vaughan also highlighted the lack of bowling options in the current Indian team and said the need of the hour is to have more batting all-rounders, a fact which spin legend Anil Kumble has also pointed out. "How have they only got five bowling options when you think 10 or 15 years ago all of India's top six could bowl a little bit - Sachin Tendulkar, Suresh Raina, Virender Sehwag and even Sourav Ganguly?

"None of the batsmen bowl so the captain has only got five options. Their (India) bowling options are too few, they do not bat deep enough and lack spin tricks."

The team management's decision to not play leg-spinner Yuzvendra Chahal throughout the tournament also cost India dearly. "We know in T20 cricket the stats tell you a team needs a spinner who can turn it both ways. India have plenty of leg spinners. Where are they?" He also questioned India's record in major ICC tournaments and feels they need to achieve more success to justify the skill level of their players.

"India are so important for world cricket but for all the advantages India have, they must win more. Even in their own backyard at the 2016 World T20 they did not reach the final. They were nowhere last year," Vaughan wrote.

"This time it took an outrageous innings by Virat Kohli, probably the best in T20 of all time, to beat Pakistan in the group stages. They massively underachieve for their skill levels."

Coming down heavily upon the experts, Vaughan claimed they are scared to criticise India as they fear losing work or getting "hammered" on social media. "India have to be honest now. What happens when India arrive at a World Cup? Everyone plays them up. "Nobody wants to criticise them because you get hammered on social media and pundits worry about losing work in India one day," he wrote.

However, Vaughan feels now is the "time to tell it straight." "They (experts) can hide behind their great players but it is about getting a team playing the right way as a whole."