India have a problem: Nasser Hussain
Former England captain Nasser Hussain - who was in the Sky Sports' commentary box during the third ODI highlighted Indian batters' perineal problem against quality left-arm pace and also cited the examples of Pakistan pacers Mohammed Amir and Shaheen Shah Afridi. Amir - demolished India's top-order in the final of Champions Trophy 2017 - while Afridi ran through the Indian batting line-up in the T20 World Cup 2021 in the UAE.
"I have a feeling India have a problem against left-armers in all formats. I think of Shaheen Shah Afridi in the T20 World Cup and Mohammad Amir in the Champions Trophy final in 2017 and Reece Topley in this series," Hussain remarked during the 3rd ODI.
India's long history of struggle
Not just Topley, Amir, or Afridi, there have been several left-arm pacers in the past who have exploited this weakness of the Indian batters. In not so distant past, Team India was tormented by young South Africa pacer Marco Jansen and English all-rounder Sam Curran in the red-ball formats, and India's dream of creating history on foreign soil was tarnished.
We have seen Australia's Mitchell Starc and Mitchell Johnson, New Zealand's Trent Boult, legendary Pakistan pacer Wasim Akram, Australian pace legends Mike Whitney and Bruce Reid, South Africa's Brett Schulz, West Indies quick Pedro Collins, and Sri Lankan great Chaminda Vaas getting the better of Indian batters in the past.
In the 2000s, tall Australia left-arm seamer Nathan Brakken had troubled the Indian batters in the ODIs.
Performances of Indian batters against left-arm pacers
Rohit averages a healthy 48.72 against southpaws in the ODIs but the Indian captain has been dismissed 28 times in 113 innings.
Kohli averages 45.93 against left-armers in the ODIs but the batting maestro became their victim on 30 occasions in 108 innings.
Dhawan has also had his fair share of struggles against southpaws and has been dismissed on 26 occasions in 72 innings. He averages 37.50 against left-arm quicks.
Virender Sehwag - who was often trapped by southpaws in the ODIs - was dismissed by left-arm quicks on 33 occasions and averaged 31.48.
Batting great Sachin Tendulkar became a victim of the left-arm seamers on 23 occasions and averaged 47.21.
India's current head coach Rahul Dravid has been dismissed nine times by southpaws and averaged 44.22 in 55 innings. Being the coach Dravid - who is often hailed as one of the most technically sound batters of his era - can now look to address this age-old problem of the Indian batters.
Reason behind Indian batters' struggle against left-arm pace
Many right-handed batsmen in world cricket (both past and present) have had discomfort against left-arm pacers and Indians are no exception. But with the brand of cricket and the upward curve that Team India has maintained leaves one wondering about their toils.
The left-arm pacers trouble Indian batters, especially in the swinging conditions, because of the angle they make when they come over the wicket. The angle at which they bowl is very difficult to play for right-handed batsmen. And if the bowlers have that extra pace and bounce, they turn out to be India's nemesis like Mitchell Starc, Mohammad Aamir, and Trent Boult.
The Men In Blue will have to work hard on this front and inculcate the habit of how well to counter left-arm pacers to the younger generation. Team India has already paid a heavy price - on numerous occasions - by losing crucial matches, series, and trophies for the opposition has exploited this chink in their armour.